author-img
Laurence Bohan
Content Writer
Laurence Bohan
Content Writer

Laurence is a copywriter and trained journalist. His passion is creating insightful and educational content for dental professionals of every level. Outside of work, he enjoys watching sport, quizzing and spending time with his family.

What is the Difference Between Etch-and-Rinse and Self-Etch Systems and What are the Main Advantages of the Two Application Methods?

In aesthetic dentistry many different routes lead to the same goal. A universal adhesive system can considerably simplify the clinical workflow of many different direct or indirect restorative treatments.

Bonding mechanism: An adhesive bond is created by dissolving calcium and phosphate components in the tooth structure and then infiltrating the porous tooth surface with a low-viscosity composite resin (bonding agent).

To establish a long-lasting bond between the composite resin and the tooth, their surfaces must be brought into close proximity to one another. Adhesive systems (bonding agents) produce ideal conditions. The current adhesive systems are divided into the following categories:

  • 3-step etch-and-rinse
  • 2-step etch-and-rinse
  • self-etch

Each of these techniques has certain advantages.

The Foundation of a Strong Adhesive Bond: Conditioning of the Tooth Surface

In the conventional etch technique, a micro-retentive pattern is etched on the tooth surface: In other words, the smear layer of the tooth is removed with phosphoric acid and the tooth structure is superficially demineralised. In this process, the top-most components of the dental enamel are dissolved and rinsed away. The inorganic components of dentine are removed according to the same principle. However, in this case a network of organic collagen fibrils remains and the conditioning of dentine is more complicated than that of enamel. Etching with phosphoric acid also exposes dentine tubules, which are susceptible to postoperative sensitivity.

The challenge: The tooth surface (particularly dentine) is hydrophilic, while composite resin is generally hydrophobic. An effective adhesive system must be capable of generating a bond to both types of surfaces.



The Difference Between Etch-and-Rinse and Self-Etch Systems


Etch-and-rinse systems require the cavity to be conventionally conditioned with phosphoric acid. Subsequently, the adhesive system is applied to the prepared tooth surface. In contrast, self-etch adhesive systems do not require separate etching. The tooth structure is conditioned by functional monomers that are contained in the adhesive system. The enamel can be additionally etched or conditioned to enhance the quality of the bond (selective enamel etching).


Etch-and-rinse adhesives, which are often referred to as the gold standard, generate the best possible bond to enamel, particularly on unprepared enamel, while self-etch adhesives are easier to use and minimise the risk of postoperative sensitivity.
Ultimate Guide to Dental Composites | Kent Express
Guide to Dental Composites
Looking for the best dental composites for your practice? Check out Kent Express' comprehensive buying guide, with tips and recommendations for every need.
Self-etch Systems and How they Differ


Self-etch systems are divided into several subcategories. Depending on whether a separate primer must be used, a distinction is made between two-step self-etch and one-step, two-component self-etch adhesives. The latest generation involves one-step, one-component self-etch adhesives (e.g. Adhese Universal).


One-step, one-component self-etch adhesives (e.g. Adhese Universal) are the only real all-in-one systems available: conditioning, priming and application are accomplished in one step due to a sophisticated formulation – Click. Bond. Done.


These universal adhesive systems are much easier to use because they do not require any premixing or application in multiple steps. Straightforward systems such as these save time and reduce the possibility of handling errors. In addition, they lower the risk of postoperative sensitivity, since the self-etch process is quite gentle.


The main advantage of the self-etch technique is that the tooth structure is simultaneously conditioned and infiltrated. This method simplifies and shortens the bonding procedure. It is easy to use, less technique sensitive and produces reliable bonding results.
image
Click and Bond: A Universal All-in-One System


A self-etch adhesive that comprises the primer and adhesive in one material is known as an all-in-one system. Only one component is responsible for the etching, priming and bonding operations.


Adhese Universal is one example of this type of product. This universal adhesive system is capable of generating a strong bond to a wide variety of restorative materials due to its sophisticated formulation.


Adhese Universal has both hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties. As a result, it produces a homogenous and stable film layer which is technique tolerant.


At the same time, Adhese Universal establishes a lasting strong bond on enamel and dentine, irrespective of the etching protocol used (etch-and-rinse, self-etch, selective enamel etch). Adhese Universal optimally wets dentine and enamel. It penetrates the dentine tubules and seals them, thereby effectively reducing the risk of postoperative sensitivity.
Copyright ® 2024 Kent Express Ltd. All rights reserved.